“The company has over 3,300 acres in land bank which is all unused. That itself is worth over Rs 100 billion. The rest in assets makes the valuation of the company around Rs 160 billion,” a source close to the company said.
In letters, the minority shareholders as well as a group of homebuyers asked for re-evaluation of the bids and wanted their requests be considered; a slash in the valuation would seriously dilute the money they would otherwise get from the deal.
As observed from the objections filed by JIL in the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), on a conservative basis, the value of its assets is much higher than the total borrowing of approximately Rs 90 billion including overdue interest, the minority shareholders have stated in their letter to the resolution professional.
It is further shocking to know that the figures of valuation for the company now being quoted are far below those admitted and sworn only a few months ago by IDBI Bank in their application before the NCLT, the letter stated.
They have now requested for a clarification on the position of the resolution professional and also protect the interests of all stakeholders before recommending any resolution plan to the CoC, the NCLT, and the Supreme Court (SC).
A group of homebuyers, on the other hand, is aggrieved that the evaluation criteria for the bids are heavily loaded in favour of financial creditors. It said the evaluation criteria were not shown to any of the amici curiae appointed by the Supreme Court for approval.
On a petition of homebuyers, the SC had appointed Shekhar Naphade, senior advocate, and Shubhangi Tuli, an advocate, as amici curiae to espouse the cause of homebuyers in the CoC.
The homebuyers, in the letter, claimed that the quantitative part of the evaluation criteria gave only 25 points to homebuyers and 45 to financial creditors.
Currently, homebuyers are not given the status of financial creditors. An official committee to review the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code did recommend placing homebuyers on a par with financial creditors, but those suggestions are yet to be incorporated in the law by the government.
However, the SC had directed the resolution professional to protect the interests of homebuyers in the resolution plan.
This is not the first time. Questions have been raised on the valuation of the company. India Infrastructure Finance (IIFCL), which has claims of about Rs 9 billion, or 10.57 per cent of Jaypee’s total debt, wants a “fair and transparent” process adopted and the current evaluation that pegs the company’s worth at less than half of its market value, which it pegged at Rs 171.1 billion, be “summarily scrapped.”
IIFCL, in a letter to the resolution professional, tore into its valuers assuming a much less toll collection from the Jaypee-built expressway. “The valuation conducted by the lenders consortium recently during 2017, the pessimist scenario for the toll collection from the expressway aggregate to Rs 67,980 crore (Rs 679.8 billion) during the remaining concession period i.e., from April 2018 to August 2048”, it wrote.
“Considering a discounting factor of 8 per cent per annum, the net present value works out to Rs 15,426 crore (Rs 154.26 billion). However, the valuer had assigned a valuation of Rs 2,395 crore (Rs 23.95 billion) only,” it pointed out.
NCLT suggests IBBI review insolvency code regulations
The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has suggested to IBBI that there is a need to review the insolvency code regulations to ensure that they are not “misused or misinterpreted.” It also said that the resolution professional (RP) should be competent and independent so that there are no interruptions in the process which lead to delays in disposal of insolvency cases. Besides, it has said the claims of operational creditors are neglected or ignored as the Committee of Creditors (CoC) has supremacy of the financial creditors (banks and financial institutions) who have control over the entire process. Nobody is taking care of operational creditors' claim, said the NCLT Kolkata Bench in its order passed last week on the Binani Cement matter. PTI