In April 2018, the Trai data had shown a net decline of 58 million mobile phone users. This was, however, primarily due to Aircel filing for bankruptcy proceedings, after which the company’s roughly 74-million customer base reduced to zero.
Earlier, in January 2018 there was a 1.3 per cent (15.5 million) decline in the mobile subscriber base after Reliance Communications shut down its mobile phone calling services in December 2017 and subscriber losses by Aircel, Telenor and Tata Teleservices.
The March numbers, however, reflect a different trend — that of cleaning up low-paying subscriber bases to improve the average revenue per user (ARPU), a strategy adopted by Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea since the third quarter of FY19. “Both the companies
want to focus on the paying subscriber base. They are cleaning up their subscriber bases to improve ARPU and improve their Ebitda margins,” said a Mumbai-based analyst.
Morgan Stanley analysts noted in a recent report that Vodafone Idea reported a 35-million reduction in the subscriber base in the third quarter of FY19 and another 53 million in the fourth, resulting in a subscriber base of 334 million at the end of March. The analysts also noted, “Airtel also reported a 48.5 mn reduction in Q3FY19, but the movement in Q4FY19 has still not been disclosed due to the ongoing rights issue.”
Experts say the decline in numbers is a positive for the incumbents. “The companies
decided to shed the 'incoming only' customers, which had choked the network of these service providers,” another Mumbai-based analyst said.
The results are showing. The Trai data showed the proportion of active wireless subscribers, which is measured through the VLR metric, had improved.
Bharti Airtel has the maximum proportion (100.82 per cent) of its active wireless subscribers as against its wireless subscribers on the date of peak VLR in March 2019. In the fourth quarter of FY19, Vodafone Idea posted a 17 per cent quarter-on-quarter (QoQ) improvement in ARPU (Rs 104) while analysts estimate Bharti Airtel’s ARPU improved by 21 per cent QoQ. Amid the subscriber losses by the two incumbents, Jio was the only mobile service provider that witnessed a growth rate of 3.19 per cent in wireless subscribers in March. The monthly decline rates of urban and rural wireless subscription in March were 0.93 per cent and 2.99 per cent, respectively. As of March 31, 2019, the private access service providers held 89.74 per cent market share of the wireless subscribers whereas BSNL and MTNL, the two public-sector access service providers, had a market share of only 10.26 per cent.
Of the 22 service areas, six showed positive growth in wireless users in March 2019. The Assam service area showed maximum growth of 2.46 per cent and the Bihar service area showed the maximum decline (4.52 per cent) in their wireless subscribers during the month. As of March 31, the top five wireless broadband service providers were Jio (306.72 million), Airtel (112.26 million), Vodafone Idea (110.20 million), BSNL (12.93 million) and Tata Teleservices (1.68 million).