West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra said the Centre should borrow to compensate the states.
The GST Council
meeting on Friday will have two objectives — addressing the government’s grim revenue position amid the pandemic and fixing the compensation mechanism for the states — given the background of a shortfall in goods and services tax (GST).
The government has rung up just about Rs 95,000 crore as GST in April and May together, and that is less than half compared with the collection in the corresponding months last year.
With the dwindling collection of cess, which goes into the compensation fund, the council will discuss alternative means such as borrowing from the market and extending the cess period by another year or two to repay.
The 40th GST Council
meeting, to be held through video-conferencing, will also discuss ways to provide relief to sectors and businesses affected by the pandemic.
They include waiving late fees for not filing GST returns
since the introduction of the tax in 2017.
Changes in rates are unlikely to be decided in the meeting.
“The state governments are under financial stress. The core agenda (of the meeting) will centre around compensation to them. Borrowing from the market seems like a feasible solution because the revenue outlook for the fiscal year appears bleak,” said a government official.
He said while collection in April and May had been less than half the usual, tinkering with rates might not be practical at this point.
“A rate cut to drive demand may not help because the rates of essentials are already low and disposable income has been affected due to the pandemic. Besides, there is no study to show how a rate cut will impact demand at this time. The rest will be up to the states,” he said.
The Centre could collect just Rs 990 crore as compensation cess in April 2020-21, a little more than one-ninth of the Rs 8,874 a year ago, according to the figures released by the Controller General of Accounts.
Under law, if the states’ GST does not grow by at least 14 per cent over the base year of 2014-15, the Centre pays them the difference every two months for the first five years of GST implementation.
Last week, the Centre released compensation of Rs 36,400 crore to the states for three months up to February 2020, utilising the undistributed integrated GST.
The GST compensation
of Rs 1.15 trillion for period April-November 2019 was released earlier.
This stands against Rs 95,551 crore collected as cess in 2019-20. The Centre used the Rs 47,271 crore surplus cess from 2017-18 and 2018-19 for distributing the excess amount last year. As such it had about Rs 1.43 trillion in its cess kitty but gave about Rs 1.52 trillion to the states. This means it paid about Rs 8,674 crore extra.
The March dues are yet to be paid.
“The GST Council is neither a sovereign nor a sub-sovereign body. So even if you take a loan, somebody has to give the guarantee. If the Central government gives guarantee to loans, it can itself borrow,” he said.
“Alternatively, the Centre should consider paying the states from the Consolidated Fund of India. States are in very bad shape. West Bengal collected only 13 per cent of GST revenue in April of the same period last year,” he said.
Kerala Finance Minister Thomas Isaac
said the GST Council should be allowed to borrow from the markets to pay the states and simultaneously extend the compensation cess by another year or so to repay the debt.