There are indications the India in which Khan came to be is changing.
Last week filmmaker Sanjay Leela Bhansali was attacked on the sets of his film Dangal. It starred Aamir Khan who had spoken against intolerance.
How did we reach here? Till about three-four years back, it was rare for most Indians to think of their film heroes as Hindu or Muslim. Bachchan, a Hindu, is an icon for all Indians. There has never been a campaign from non-Hindus to not watch his films. Ditto for Dilip Kumar (Yusuf Khan), Raj Kapoor, Dev Anand, Rajendra Kumar, Rajesh Khanna — all the superstars of yore had a following among Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Parsis and other Indians. They played characters from different communities. Bachchan’s Iqbal in Lagaan (2001) was loved by all Indians.
Are we seeing the beginning of the communalising of one of the most iconic film industries in the world?
India’s cinema is a proud hallmark of its soft power — eliciting both admiration and anxiety. Baz Luhrmann (3 Idiots (2009) in China created internal discussions within that country on how it could improve its “soft power” quotient. India is among a handful of countries that has a vibrant, commercially dominant local film industry that is not swamped by Hollywood.
This is because it is inclusive, meritocratic and has a completely local creative idiom. It is, arguably, one of the few professional spaces where Indians don’t face any caste, class or religious discrimination. As an outsider the only thing you really need is talent and grit; ask Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Vishal Bhardwaj, Deepika Padukone or Kangana Ranaut.
There are two arguments against the worry on creeping communalism.
One, these incidents are outbursts by the fringe and film-makers should really learn to stand up for their creative convictions when attacked.
Two, Indians vote for their films with their hearts and wallets, not their religious identities. That is why this industry survived over 100 years of state neglect to become a clean, studio-led, institutionally financed, creatively vibrant business. And that is why in spite of an online slander campaign Dangal is on course to make Rs 600 crore in box-office collections across the world.